Part 3: In Search of the Perfect Camera Case for the Canon G10

This is the third, and final, installment of my Canon G10 camera case saga. If you haven't read the first, you can find it here, and the second here. I suppose it is final because I'm really tired of looking and did actually make a selection. It is also final because it really isn't final. If I come across another case I like better I'll probably buy it.

I decided I needed to really pound the pavement to see if I could find a case I liked. I went to just about any store I could think of that sells cameras. Unfortunately, the G10 size of camera is not very common. In some stores, there was a wall of cases for sub-compact, another wall for DSLRs, but few options for cameras that fit the in-between sizes range like the G10.

Cases not Chosen

So why would I include a bunch cases I didn't buy in this list. Well, my goal here was to help save some of those who read this a bit of time. You may like these cases enough to give them a try.

The Lowepro Z10 and Z20 (pictured together) would be very good choices in terms of quality. The materials are good, the workmanship is good, the padding is good... The Z10 is a good fit for the camera, but there isn't much room left over. The Z20 is a better fit and would allow you to stuff the neck strap into the top of the case. As you can see from the picture, the cases are about the same width, but the Z20 is taller. Definitely go with the Z20 if you want a place to put the neck strap.

So why didn't I like them. Well, the zippers are a pain to use. Because the whole top doesn't open, getting the camera out for that all important shot is just too problematic, especially if it is on your belt. If you're not carrying the camera on your belt, one of these would be a good choice.

Next on the try-for-yourself list is the Lowepro D Res 120. It does have a top access, so pulling the camera out is a bit easier. It is

 also a bit taller so you'll have room for the neck strap. Unfortunately, it too has a zipper and I just don't like fiddling with zippers when the case is attached to my belt. The D Res 120 case is also a bit mushy in terms of the materials. The Z10 and Z20 are more rigid due to the use of heavier materials. Had the materials been a bit more rigid, I probably would have purchased it and given it a try.

The last try-for-yourself recommendation is the Lowepro D-Pods 50. The materials are of the wetsuit variety, so it is a very flexible case. The padding is good, but way too mushy for my taste. I almost purchased this case, but gave the following 2 cases the slight advantage. And the winners are:

And the winner (Actually Winners): Tamrac  5689 & 5692

OK, why 2 winners? Well, I have 2 applications. The first is to carry the camera around on short outings. For that, the 5689 is perfect. I like the materials, though they could be a bit stiffer, and the zipper free opening with just a velcro latch. I also like the belt loop. which allows the case to be attached to the belt without taking the belt off. It has a double velcro system that is perhaps it is not quite as secure as a sewn in belt loop, but you won't be scaring anyone when you start to undo your belt either. It is also just deep enough to hold the camera and the neck strap or, my preference, a hand strap. It has an extra storage pouch for a memory card, but that's about all the extra stuff you're going to carry with this case. Here are a few pictures of the 8689 to give you an idea:

Tamrac 5689 with G10 halfway inserted

Tamrac 5689 closed

  

Tamrac 5689 belt loop which is secured to case with velcro and resecured with a velcro tab

The Tamrac 5692 is just about identical to the 5689 in size, however, it has an additional little storage pouch on the front of the case. This would allow you to add an extra battery, perhaps some AA batteries for an external flash, memory card... The case flap also has velcro but adds a plastic latch. I'm not sure why they have both. I think the latch might just get in the way, but if you're concerned about pick-pockets, the latch should give you a bit of extra confidence. The belt loop attachment is also of the variety that does not require taking your belt off. Finally, it is also fitted for and comes with a shoulder strap. I bought this one to use on my motorcycle, where I can just throw the shoulder strap around my head and arm and have easy access to the camera. Here are a few pics to give you a better idea of what the case looks like:

Tamrac 5692 w/G10 halfway in

Tamrac 5692 closed and latched

  

Tamrac 5692 showing the belt loop which secures with snaps and velcro

Part 2: In Search of the Perfect Camera Case for the Canon G10

As promised, here's the second installment in my search for the perfect Canon G10 camera case. If you haven't read Part 1, you will find it here. 

Case No. 2: Canon PSC-5000

The PSC-5000 is a case designed for the G7 and G9. Although Canon doesn't seem to recommend it as an option for the G10, I think it is worth looking at. It is a funky design with a few shortcomings, but you will fall in love with the quality and workmanship of this case.

Ok, lets talk about the shortcomings first. The camera fits into the case pocket very nicely, but it is about 2 or 3 mm too tall. This makes lid flap sit just a bit too high and, if you look closely at the picture of the camera closed in the case, you'll notice the top flap is sticking up just a bit. I'm just guessing here, but I think the case would form to the camera over time and this issue would go away -- assuming it is an issue for you.

Shortcoming number 2 is related to its design. It is, well, different in an odd sort of way. Once you put the camera into the case, you flip up a lower flap, and fasten a top flap to the lower flap. I don't think all this flap action is really necessary, but it is different. One person's different is another persons funky, so it might not be a problem for you. I would have just preferred a single flap over the top that fastened on the side of the case. As a side note, the flaps use those little magnetic snaps that don't really snap.

Shortcoming number 3 was the deal breaker for me, and it all hinges on the fact that I prefer to use a wrist strap instead of a neck strap. Because the case is rigid and the fit is snug, you can't get the camera out of the case by lifting only one side at a time. Short of standing on my head and enlisting the aid of gravity, it wasn't easy to get the camera out when it was on my belt. If you'll be using a neck strap, you can tug on both sides to pull it out easily. If you do use a neck strap and want to wear this case on your belt, you might give some thought to where you'll be putting the neck strap, there isn't room in the case. 

Ok, now the positives. This is a first rate case. The workmanship is top notch and the leather is very nice. They even provide a cute little pouch for your battery and extra memory card. A very nice touch. As mentioned prior, it is a rigid case, so protection from sharp objects should be very good.

All in all, the PSC-5000 would be a classy way to carry the camera around, but it isn't all that functional. It would look good sitting in a coach purse or hanging around your neck when you toss the Ferrari's keys to the valet. For me, back to the store it goes.

Ranking: A+ for quality and workmanship, A for funky appeal, C+ for camera fit, and a C+/B for protection. Like the PSC-85, the rigid case will help with sharp object intrusion into the case (B), but should the case get dropped, there isn't much padding (C+).

Camera Case No. 3: You can find the third and final posting here.

Update:

This case is commonly available at places like bhphotovideo.com, at least for now. Since it was designed for the G7 & G9, it probably won't be available for that much longer.

In Search of the Perfect Camera Case for the Canon G10

I am really picky about my camera cases. Not so much because I have a set criteria, but because there are so many intangibles associated with picking a camera case. It's a little like choosing your doctor. Yes, you heard me right. There are things about a case you just can't put your finger on. The feel, the materials, the workmanship... I always have the same feeling when I choose a new doctor, but that's a different blog. Let me just say that in both instances I start out clueless, get a little smarter after a bit of research, then just pick one, or two, or three. Now you know the truth. I have three cases for my Nikon D700. Luckily, I don't have that many doctors at the moment.

I thought a chronicle of the process might be useful to others. If I can help you choose a good case for your G10, fantastic! Just don't ask me about doctors.

Camera Case No. 1: The Canon PSC-85

I started this quest like all others, by researching all the options. I finished by getting tired of researching all the options and just bought one. It was, however, the only one that had official documentation that stated it would fit the G10. Canon didn't say it would fit, but Cameta Camera did, via their ebay ad. Well, it kind of fits, like the suit I wore to my high school prom fits. Tight. Very tight. Seam ripping tight. Otherwise, its a great case.

As you can see from the picture, the camera is as wide as the outside of the case. Because the case is a little deeper (front to back) than the camera, it is able to deform from its original shape and become wider. For a really soft case, that might not be a problem. What the pictures don't show, however, is that this case is of the more rigid type. There is some kind of flexible plastic sandwiched between the outer and inner layers. It does give a bit, but not without a fight. The camera is a bit too long as well, so when you finally wrestle the camera into the case, the flap misses the velcro by about 3/4".

Aside from the fit issue, this would be a great case for a smaller camera. The materials and workmanship are very good. There isn't a lot of padding, but there is some. As stated earlier, it is semi rigid, so it would probably keep sharp objects from poking through and damaging the camera's display or lens cover. Personally, I'm in the thin/rigid camp myself. The size of the padding does add up quickly, in terms of the volume you have to carry around.

The velcro latch is also well thought out. The velcro is quite wide and very secure once it is pressed down. I also like the small zipper pouch with just enough room for a memory card. If you were thinking of packing batteries around, it wouldn't be large enough for you. Since the G10's battery is probably going to outlast me, I'm not going to be buying a spare. The PSC-85 also has a belt loop. The loop is fairly rigid and securely sewn to the back of the case.

I really like this case. It's a shame I don't have a camera to fit it.

Ranking: A+ for quality and workmanship, D- for G10 fit, and a very subjective C+/B for protection. The C+ is for drops because there should probably be a bit more padding for that. The B is for sharp object penetration, which should be good due to the rigid inner layer.

Go to Part 2